The two names sound alike, they both start with Medi, and most people use them interchangeably until the day they need one of them to pay for something. Then the difference becomes very real. I hear the confusion on nearly every first call, and I do not blame anyone for it; I had the same confusion when my mother needed care. So here is the plain version I give families at my kitchen table.
Medicare is health insurance for people 65 and older and for some younger people with disabilities. It is federal, it does not look at your income or savings, and it pays for medical care: hospitals, doctors, tests, drugs and short stretches of rehabilitation. Medicaid is a program for people with limited income and assets, run by New York with federal money, and it is the one that pays for long term care, including a long stay in a nursing home. Neither of them pays rent in assisted living, memory care or independent living in the ordinary case, and that is the sentence I most want you to remember.
The short answer: Medicare is insurance, Medicaid is assistance
If you remember one line, remember this: Medicare pays for getting better, Medicaid pays for living with help once you have run out of money. Medicare is earned through work history and age. Medicaid is granted based on need, and it comes with an application, financial documentation and rules about what you can keep. A person can have both at once, which is called being dual eligible, and I explain how that works in who qualifies for both Medicare and Medicaid on Long Island.
My senior living FAQs page answers the most common versions of this question in a few sentences each. This post goes one level deeper so that when a hospital discharge planner or a community’s business office uses one of these words, you know which pocket they are reaching for.
What Medicare is and what it covers
Medicare is the federal health insurance program for people 65 and over, and for some younger people with long term disabilities. Most people are enrolled automatically or sign up around their 65th birthday. There is no income test and no asset test. It comes in parts: Part A covers hospital stays, short stays in a skilled nursing facility after a hospital admission, some skilled care at home and hospice. Part B covers doctors, outpatient care, tests and equipment. Part D covers prescription drugs. Part C, called Medicare Advantage, is a private plan that bundles those pieces and sometimes adds extras.
What Medicare does not cover is the thing families need most: ongoing help with bathing, dressing, meals, medications and supervision, which Medicare calls custodial care. That is why it does not pay for assisted living, memory care or independent living rent, and why it pays for a nursing home only for a limited number of days after a qualifying hospital stay. I explain the exceptions in does Medicare cover long term care.
What Medicaid is and what it covers
Medicaid is a joint federal and state program that pays for health care and long term care for people whose income and assets fall under limits the state sets. In New York it is administered through the county, which on Long Island means the Nassau or Suffolk Department of Social Services, and through the city in Queens. The limits change yearly, so confirm the current figures with the county Department of Social Services rather than with a blog post. A spouse who stays at home is allowed to keep a protected share of income and assets.
Medicaid covers what Medicare covers and a great deal more: long term nursing home stays, long term aide hours at home through managed long term care plans, and a limited amount of assisted living through a specific program with a small number of participating communities, which I describe in does Medicaid pay for assisted living in New York. It does not pay for independent living, and it does not pay for most assisted living or memory care on Long Island, where the large majority of residents pay privately.
Which one pays for what: the table I draw for families
Here is the comparison in one place. These are general rules; details vary by plan and change over time, so confirm the current ones.
| Need | Medicare | Medicaid |
|---|---|---|
| Hospital stay | Yes, with deductibles and limits | Yes, for those who qualify |
| Doctor visits, tests, equipment | Yes | Yes |
| Prescription drugs | Yes, through Part D or an Advantage plan | Yes, often covering what Medicare leaves |
| Rehab in a skilled nursing facility after a hospital stay | Up to 100 days per benefit period, with a copay after day 20 | Can pick up when Medicare stops, for those who qualify |
| Long term nursing home stay | No | Yes, the main payer in New York |
| Assisted living | No | Only through a limited program with few participating communities |
| Memory care | No | Generally no, outside that limited program |
| Independent living rent | No | No |
| Aides at home, long term | No, beyond short skilled episodes | Yes, through managed long term care for those who qualify |
| Hospice | Yes, the hospice services | Yes |
Notice the pattern. Medicare dominates the top of the table, Medicaid dominates the bottom, and the middle rows, assisted living and memory care, are mostly paid by neither. That middle is where my families live, and it is paid with savings, the house, pensions, long term care insurance and veterans benefits.
Where Long Island families get caught
The first trap is assuming Medicare will pay for a nursing home for as long as it is needed. It will not; the skilled nursing benefit is short and ends when skilled care ends, which I walk through in how long Medicare pays for a nursing home after a hospital stay. The second trap is assuming Medicaid will pay for a nice assisted living community once the savings are gone. On Long Island that path is narrow, and families who plan around it often end up choosing between a nursing home and bringing a parent home.
The third trap is timing. Medicaid looks back at financial transfers before an application and can impose a penalty period for gifts, which makes the house and the savings a subject for an elder law attorney years before anyone needs care. I explain that side in can Medicaid take your house in New York.
Will you need help filing for Medicaid in New York?
Many families do, and there is no shame in it. The application asks for months of financial records, proof of income, insurance information and, for a married applicant, the spouse’s finances too. The county reviews transfers and can deny or delay for missing documents. Here is who helps, in the order I usually suggest.
- An elder law attorney, for anyone with a house, meaningful savings or a spouse at home, because the planning decisions come before the application. If dementia is part of the picture, first read whether a parent with dementia can still sign.
- The hospital or nursing home social worker, who files applications for long term nursing home residents every week.
- The county Department of Social Services, which can answer eligibility questions and provide the forms.
- A benefits counselor through a local aging services office, for the Medicare side and for the programs that help pay Medicare premiums.
My role sits beside all of that. I am not a lawyer or a benefits counselor; I find the right community for the care need and the budget, and I make sure the money conversation, including which program will pay and when, happens before the move rather than after it. I have toured more than 90 communities across Nassau, Suffolk and Queens, and I plan 18 to 24 months past the move so that if Medicaid is in the future, we choose a community with that in mind.
One call sorts out which program matters for your parent
Assisted Living Locators of Long Island helps families across Nassau, Suffolk and Queens understand which program pays for what, then find the assisted living, memory care or independent living community that fits. The help is free to families; communities compensate the advisor when a family moves in. If you need an elder law attorney or a benefits counselor, I will tell you so and point you toward one.
My office is at 42 Prospect Ave, Glen Cove, NY 11542. Tell me what coverage your parent has, and we will go through it on one call.
Questions readers ask
Can my mother have Medicare and Medicaid at the same time?
Yes. People who meet Medicare’s age or disability rules and New York’s income and asset limits are dual eligible. Medicare pays first for medical care and Medicaid picks up premiums, copays and long term care.
Which program pays for memory care on Long Island?
In most cases neither. Memory care is paid privately, with long term care insurance or veterans benefits where they apply. Medicaid reaches assisted living only through a limited program, and Medicare does not pay for it at all.
Is Medicaid the same in every state?
No. The federal government sets a framework and each state sets its own limits, programs and procedures. The rules in this post are about New York, and the figures change yearly, so confirm them with the county.
Does signing up for Medicaid mean giving up Medicare?
No. Medicare stays your primary insurance. Medicaid becomes secondary and covers costs Medicare leaves, including long term care that Medicare never covered in the first place.
Read next
Watch: Mike explains
The 5 Legal Documents Every Senior Needs (Before a Crisis)
When a health crisis hits, the families who suffer most are the ones missing paperwork. In this video, Mike McClernon walks through the five...
Next step: see Mike’s guide to senior housing on Long Island, or browse the Long Island community profiles.
